- Joined
- Oct 19, 2019
- Messages
- 6,237
- Reaction score
- 5,626
Probably not too many players starting with the letter I for tomorrow.
I've already made the list... it's not pretty

Quote of the Day - "The difference between screwing around and science is writing it down." ~ Adam Savage
Probably not too many players starting with the letter I for tomorrow.
ummmmmmmmmI've already made the list... it's not pretty![]()
ummmmmmmmm
Raul Ibanez
Jason Isringhausen
that's all i've got![]()
I thought this allowed you to change your vote if you wanted to, but it doesn't seem to be letting me do that.
Half these guys I never heard of. Eeny, meeny, miny, moe.I've already made the list... it's not pretty![]()
Maybe but even if he were he'd still rank 3rd among OFers on this list alone behind Reggie and Andruw Jones. And Bottom line is there are only 4 OF spots left, one of which I have reserved for the letter 'W' for some dude named Teddy, and another bench OF spot needs to stay open for the only MLB player EVER whose last name began with the letter X.Aaron judge should be on here
Aaron judge should be on here
I take Aaron judge over both of them . Especially peak judgeMaybe but even if he were he'd still rank 3rd among OFers on this list alone behind Reggie and Andruw Jones. And Bottom line is there are only 4 OF spots left, one of which I have reserved for the letter 'W' for some dude named Teddy, and another bench OF spot needs to stay open for the only MLB player EVER whose last name began with the letter X.
Maybe but even if he were he'd still rank 3rd among OFers on this list alone behind Reggie and Andruw Jones. And Bottom line is there are only 4 OF spots left, one of which I have reserved for the letter 'W' for some dude named Teddy, and another bench OF spot needs to stay open for the only MLB player EVER whose last name began with the letter
I stuck with outfielders who can catch...![]()
![]()
I don't. Reggie was a lot more clutch than Judge, and peak Andruw Jones was a monster on both sides of the ball.I take Aaron judge over both of them . Especially peak judge
I can argue Bernie Williams was more clutch than Ted Williams. Judge even as a bad center fielder atill had a season that Andrew jones could never touchI don't. Reggie was a lot more clutch than Judge, and peak Andruw Jones was a monster on both sides of the ball.